With Pete Alonso Back, Here’s What the Mets’ Power-Packed 2025 Lineup Could Look Like! 💥
The return of Pete Alonso to the New York Mets cements a vital piece of their offensive core as they look to make a strong push in the 2025 season. With Alonso anchoring the lineup, the Mets have the potential to field one of the most dangerous offensive units in Major League Baseball.
After a disappointing 2023 and a transition year in 2024, the Mets, under owner Steve Cohen, have made it clear that they are committed to building a contender. The question now is: What will the lineup look like in 2025? With a mix of returning stars, emerging prospects, and potential offseason acquisitions, the Mets could feature a formidable combination of power, speed, and versatility.
Let’s break down what the Mets’ batting order could look like on Opening Day 2025.
Projected 2025 New York Mets Lineup
1. Brandon Nimmo – CF
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .280 AVG / .385 OBP / 18 HR / 70 RBI / 90 R
Brandon Nimmo remains the ideal leadoff hitter for the Mets. He gets on base at an elite level, providing stability at the top of the order. Nimmo’s ability to work counts, draw walks, and set the tone for the offense makes him an invaluable piece. Defensively, he’s improved in center field, and with the Mets committed to competing, they will rely on his consistency to start the lineup strong.
2. Francisco Lindor – SS
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .270 AVG / .345 OBP / 25 HR / 90 RBI / 20 SB
Francisco Lindor remains the heart and soul of the Mets. After a stellar 2022 and 2023, he continued to prove why he’s one of the best all-around shortstops in baseball. Batting second, he provides both power and speed, making him a constant threat to drive in runs or create havoc on the bases. Defensively, he’s a Gold Glove-caliber shortstop who brings leadership and experience to the team.
3. Pete Alonso – 1B
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .260 AVG / .350 OBP / 45 HR / 115 RBI
With Alonso back in the fold, the Mets have one of the most dangerous power hitters in baseball hitting in the heart of their order. Alonso’s ability to hit 40+ home runs a season makes him the primary run-producer. Opposing pitchers fear his presence, and with the right lineup protection, he could post another MVP-caliber campaign.
His return also ensures leadership in the clubhouse. Known for his enthusiasm and competitive spirit, Alonso is more than just a slugger—he’s a cornerstone of the franchise.
4. J.D. Martinez (Free Agent Signing) – DH
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .275 AVG / .360 OBP / 30 HR / 90 RBI
The Mets need another right-handed power bat to protect Alonso, and a short-term deal with J.D. Martinez would provide just that. Even at 37, Martinez remains a force at the plate, and as a designated hitter, he could still deliver 30 home runs while maintaining a strong on-base percentage.
Adding a veteran like Martinez would balance the lineup, ensuring that teams can’t pitch around Alonso too easily. His postseason experience would also be valuable for a Mets team looking to make a deep playoff run.
5. Brett Baty – 3B
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .270 AVG / .340 OBP / 20 HR / 80 RBI
After some early struggles, Brett Baty finally breaks out in 2025. The Mets’ patience with their young third baseman pays off as he solidifies himself as an everyday player. With smooth defense and a growing offensive skill set, Baty becomes a crucial piece in the middle of the order.
If he can develop into a reliable 20-home-run threat with a strong OBP, he gives the Mets a much-needed left-handed presence behind Alonso and Martinez.
6. Starling Marte – RF
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .265 AVG / .330 OBP / 15 HR / 25 SB
Injuries slowed down Marte in recent seasons, but if healthy, he remains a valuable asset in the Mets’ lineup. While he may not be the same player he was during his All-Star season, Marte still brings speed, veteran presence, and occasional power.
If the Mets acquire another outfielder or move Marte in a trade, this spot could be filled by a younger player. But for now, Marte slots in as a solid contributor.
7. Francisco Álvarez – C
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .250 AVG / .330 OBP / 30 HR / 75 RBI
Francisco Álvarez emerged as one of the best power-hitting catchers in the league. By 2025, he could be one of the most dangerous hitters in the Mets’ lineup. At just 23 years old, his combination of power and improving defense makes him a long-term piece of the Mets’ core.
Having a catcher who can hit 30+ home runs is a luxury most teams don’t have. Álvarez continues his development and solidifies his place as one of baseball’s best young stars.
8. Jeff McNeil – 2B
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .285 AVG / .345 OBP / 10 HR / 60 RBI
McNeil provides versatility and contact hitting from the bottom of the order. Though his power is limited, his ability to put the ball in play and move runners over makes him an invaluable piece.
As long as he stays healthy, McNeil continues to be a key part of the Mets’ offense and a Gold Glove-caliber defender at second base.
9. Jett Williams – LF (Top Prospect Promotion)
Key Stats (2024 Projection): .270 AVG / .350 OBP / 12 HR / 25 SB
By 2025, top prospect Jett Williams could find himself as a regular in the Mets’ lineup. His ability to get on base, combined with his speed, makes him an intriguing addition. If the Mets decide to give him a full-time role, he could provide a dynamic element to the bottom of the order.
If Williams isn’t ready, the Mets could look at re-signing someone like Mark Canha or acquiring another bat in free agency.
The Mets’ 2025 Lineup at a Glance
- Brandon Nimmo – CF (On-base machine, table-setter)
- Francisco Lindor – SS (Power-speed threat, leader)
- Pete Alonso – 1B (MVP-caliber power)
- J.D. Martinez – DH (Veteran slugger, Alonso protection)
- Brett Baty – 3B (Breakout young star)
- Starling Marte – RF (Speed, contact, veteran presence)
- Francisco Álvarez – C (Elite power from the catcher position)
- Jeff McNeil – 2B (Bat-to-ball skills, versatility)
- Jett Williams – LF (Young speedster, future star)
Final Thoughts: A Lineup Built to Win
With Pete Alonso back and the right mix of veterans, prospects, and potential free-agent signings, the Mets could have a powerful lineup capable of competing in the National League. The key will be balance—ensuring that Alonso has protection in the lineup while also getting consistent production from the bottom half.
If the Mets can pair this offense with strong pitching, 2025 could be the year they make a legitimate World Series push. Let’s Go Mets! 🚀💥
