Mets Projected Lineup After the Alonso Signing
The New York Mets made a significant move by re-signing slugger Pete Alonso, solidifying their offensive core for the 2025 season. With his powerful bat returning to the heart of the order, the Mets lineup now takes shape as a formidable force capable of competing with the best in the league. Alonso’s presence ensures stability and run production, but how does the rest of the lineup look?
In this analysis, we’ll break down the Mets’ projected batting order, how Alonso’s signing impacts the offense, and what this means for their playoff hopes.
1. Brandon Nimmo (CF)
Brandon Nimmo remains the perfect leadoff hitter for the Mets. With his elite on-base skills, solid contact ability, and above-average speed, he sets the table for the big bats behind him. Nimmo’s patience at the plate allows him to work deep counts, drawing walks and getting on base at a high rate. His ability to get on base consistently is crucial, as it provides RBI opportunities for the power hitters in the middle of the order.
In 2024, Nimmo posted an on-base percentage (OBP) above .370, proving he remains one of the best leadoff men in the game. While he may not be a stolen base threat like traditional leadoff hitters, his ability to score from first on extra-base hits makes him a valuable asset atop the order.
2. Francisco Lindor (SS)
Francisco Lindor serves as the perfect No. 2 hitter, bringing a combination of power, speed, and defensive excellence. While he struggled at times with consistency last season, he still managed to hit over 25 home runs and drive in 90+ runs.
Lindor’s switch-hitting ability allows the Mets to maintain balance in the lineup, and his improved discipline at the plate ensures he can move runners over or drive them in when needed. Having him in the No. 2 spot also benefits the Mets defensively, as he anchors the infield with Gold Glove-caliber play.
3. Juan Soto (RF)
One of the biggest factors in shaping the Mets’ lineup is the presence of Juan Soto. Acquired via a blockbuster trade, Soto brings one of the best bats in baseball to Queens. His elite plate discipline, power, and ability to get on base make him an ideal fit in the No. 3 spot.
Soto’s ability to draw walks and see a high number of pitches per at-bat makes life difficult for opposing pitchers. In 2024, he posted an OPS well over .900, further solidifying his reputation as one of the game’s best hitters. With runners on base, Soto is a nightmare for pitchers, as he can drive the ball to all fields and capitalize on any mistake.
4. Pete Alonso (1B)
The heart of the Mets lineup features their franchise cornerstone, Pete Alonso. His recent signing ensures that New York retains one of the most prolific power hitters in the game. With multiple 40+ home run seasons under his belt, Alonso remains a key run producer for the team.
His presence in the No. 4 spot means pitchers will be forced to pick their poison—either pitch to Alonso with men on base or take their chances with the hitters behind him. Having Soto ahead of him increases Alonso’s RBI opportunities, making a 100+ RBI season a strong possibility.
Defensively, Alonso has worked to improve his fielding at first base, but his value remains in his bat. His ability to change the game with one swing makes him indispensable to the Mets’ lineup.
5. Starling Marte (LF)
When healthy, Starling Marte provides speed and veteran leadership to the Mets’ lineup. While injuries have limited his production in recent years, a bounce-back season could be in store for the veteran outfielder.
Marte’s ability to hit for average, steal bases, and contribute defensively gives the Mets versatility. If he can return to his 2022 form—when he hit .290 with 16 home runs and 18 stolen bases—the Mets’ offense will be even more dangerous.
6. J.D. Martinez (DH)
The Mets needed a veteran power bat in the designated hitter role, and J.D. Martinez fits the bill. Coming off a productive year where he slugged over .500, Martinez still has the ability to drive the ball out of the park.
While his strikeout rate has increased with age, Martinez remains a serious threat against both righties and lefties. His experience in big games adds another element of leadership, and he provides additional protection for Alonso in the lineup.
7. Brett Baty (3B)
Brett Baty is expected to take another step forward in 2025. The young third baseman has shown flashes of power but struggled with consistency at the plate. If he can improve his contact rate and cut down on strikeouts, he could solidify himself as the everyday third baseman.
Defensively, Baty has worked to improve his glove at third base, though his range remains a work in progress. If he can put together a strong offensive season, he will provide much-needed depth in the lower half of the lineup.
8. Jeff McNeil (2B)
Jeff McNeil brings contact-hitting ability and defensive versatility to the Mets’ lineup. While his power numbers aren’t eye-catching, his ability to hit for average and put the ball in play makes him a valuable asset in the No. 8 spot.
McNeil’s ability to play multiple positions also provides manager Carlos Mendoza with flexibility. If injuries arise or lineup changes are needed, McNeil can shift to the outfield or serve as a reliable backup at third base.
9. Francisco Álvarez (C)
Rounding out the lineup is the Mets’ promising young catcher, Francisco Álvarez. His combination of power and defensive growth makes him one of the most exciting young players in baseball.
Álvarez showcased his ability to hit for power in 2024, launching over 20 home runs. His defensive work behind the plate has improved, and his rapport with the pitching staff makes him a crucial part of the team’s success. If Álvarez continues to develop at the plate, he could be a future star in New York.
How Alonso’s Signing Impacts the Lineup
By locking up Pete Alonso, the Mets maintain one of their biggest offensive weapons. His signing ensures continuity and stability in the heart of the order, allowing the team to build around their core pieces.
- Increased RBI Opportunities: With Soto and Lindor hitting ahead of him, Alonso will see more at-bats with runners on base.
- More Protection: Having a hitter like J.D. Martinez behind him prevents pitchers from simply pitching around Alonso.
- Clubhouse Leadership: Alonso has been a key figure in the Mets’ clubhouse, and keeping him around maintains team chemistry.
Final Thoughts: Can This Lineup Compete?
The Mets’ projected lineup after re-signing Pete Alonso looks deep, powerful, and well-balanced. With a mix of veteran experience, young talent, and proven superstars, this lineup has the potential to be one of the best in baseball.
However, success will depend on health, consistency, and key players delivering in crucial moments. If Alonso continues to be a force in the middle of the lineup and the supporting cast produces, the Mets could find themselves in contention for a deep postseason run.
With spring training approaching, Mets fans have plenty to be excited about. If everything clicks, 2025 could be a special year in Queens.
