BREAKING: Saints Just Drafted Georgia DT Christen Miller — But Fans Are FURIOUS Over This One Major Red Flag!
METAIRIE, La. – The New Orleans Saints believed they had executed a masterstroke. They landed a powerful, violent, SEC-tested defensive tackle from Georgia — a program that has become the NFL’s premier talent factory. They addressed their porous run defense and an interior pass rush that ranked near the bottom of the league.
But when the Saints selected Christen Miller with the No. 93 overall pick in the third round, the reaction from the Who Dat Nation was not celebration. It was fury.
Because attached to Miller’s undeniable physical gifts is one major, glaring, impossible-to-ignore red flag: a shoulder injury so significant that multiple teams removed him from their draft boards entirely — and a medical history that screams “high-risk repeat customer.”
Here is the full story of why the Saints are betting big on a player who might not make it through training camp, and why fans are already calling this the most dangerous pick of the Loomis era.
—
The Superstar Talent: Why the Saints Fell in Love
First, let’s be clear about why the Saints drafted Miller in the first place. On pure football ability, he is a third-round steal.
At 6-foot-3 and 299 pounds, Miller possesses a rare combination of raw power and explosive first-step quickness. His 2025 season at Georgia, while not statistically dominant (28 tackles, 5.5 tackles for loss, 3 sacks), told a different story to analytics-driven front offices. Miller ranked in the 86th percentile among FBS defensive tackles in pass-rush win rate. His “hands of violence” — as scouts call them — routinely sent SEC offensive linemen backward into their own quarterbacks’ laps.
“Miller is a strong, powerful interior presence with heavy hands and a strong initial punch,” reads a consensus scouting report. “He plays with good pad level and utilizes a quick swim move to clear blockers. He is at his best when asked to fire off the ball and attack.”
For a Saints defense that ranked 22nd in sacks and 29th in rushing yards allowed per game last season, Miller is a direct schematic antidote. He can two-gap against the run on early downs and then penetrate as a three-technique on passing situations. He is, by every measure, exactly what New Orleans needed.
Defensive coordinator Joe Woods reportedly pounded the table for Miller. Head coach Kellen Moore signed off. General Manager Mickey Loomis made the call.
But then the medical report landed on the desk. And everything changed.
—
The Major Red Flag: A Torn Labrum That Won’t Stay Fixed
Here is the detail that has Saints fans seeing red.
Christen Miller played the final six games of the 2025 season with a torn labrum in his right shoulder. He did not miss a game. He gutted it out. That toughness, which the Saints have spun as a positive character trait, is actually the source of the fury.
Why? Because Miller required surgery immediately after the season. That surgery, while reportedly successful, marks the third significant shoulder procedure on the same joint since his sophomore year of high school.
Let that sink in. Three surgeries. One shoulder. Before his 24th birthday.
Multiple NFL teams, according to league sources, flagged Miller’s medicals as “high risk” or “red” — the lowest possible designation. At least four teams removed Miller from their draft boards entirely in the second round. Two teams reportedly dropped him to a Day 3 “flier” grade, meaning they would not consider him until the fifth round or later.
The concern is not whether Miller can play. The concern is whether Miller can stay on the field. Defensive tackles take more repeated blunt-force trauma to their shoulders than almost any position on the field. Every single snap, Miller will engage with 300-pound offensive linemen who will target that shoulder. Every single tackle, he will extend that arm. Every single fall, he will land on that joint.
“Once you have multiple labrum repairs on the same shoulder, the risk of re-tear increases exponentially,” an orthopedic surgeon who consults for an NFC team told this reporter on condition of anonymity. “You’re looking at a player who could need another surgery after eight games. Or he could be fine for five years. There is no middle ground. It’s a lottery ticket.”
Saints fans have heard this story before. And that is precisely why they are furious.
—
The Fan Fury: “We’ve Seen This Movie Before”
Within minutes of the Christen Miller pick being announced, social media erupted — not with joy, but with a specific, weary anger unique to New Orleans.
“ANOTHER injury-prone defensive lineman?” tweeted @SaintsSadness. “We just watched Marcus Davenport miss 40 games in five years. We watched Payton Turner play 15 games TOTAL. Now we’re doing it again with Miller? When will this front office LEARN?”
Another fan, @NOLA_TrenchWarfare, was even more direct: “I don’t care how hard he hits. If you can’t stay on the field, you’re useless. A third-round pick on a guy who might need another shoulder surgery by October is malpractice. Fire Loomis.”
The frustration is rooted in a painful pattern. The Saints have repeatedly gambled on players with extensive injury histories — and repeatedly lost.
· Marcus Davenport (2018 first round): Missed 40 of a possible 82 games.
· Payton Turner (2021 first round): Played just 15 games in three seasons.
· Michael Thomas (contract extension after injury): Played 20 games over four seasons.
· Ryan Ramczyk (knee): Forced into early retirement.
· Trevor Penning (foot, toe): Missed significant time early in his career.
The fanbase has run out of patience. They want durable, reliable, available players. Instead, they got a player who has already had three shoulder surgeries before stepping on an NFL field.
Even Miller’s own college production raises questions. After returning from his initial shoulder issues, his performance dipped noticeably. His tackling efficiency dropped from 12.4 snaps per tackle to 18.7. His pass-rush win rate, while still good, fell from elite to merely above average. Did the shoulder affect his play? The Saints say no. The tape says maybe.
—
The Saints’ Defense: “We Managed the Medicals”
Inside the Saints’ facility, the front office is well aware of the backlash — and insists they are not being reckless.
“We did an incredible amount of due diligence on Christen,” General Manager Mickey Loomis said after the pick. “We sent our team physician to Athens. We reviewed every image from every surgery. We spoke to the surgeons who performed the procedures. We believe the labrum is stable and that his playing style is not compromised.”
Kellen Moore added: “This is a football player. Not a track athlete. Not a workout warrior. A football player. His tape against SEC offensive lines is all we needed to see. We’ll manage his reps. We’ll manage his recovery. We believe in the long-term payoff.”
The Saints also point out that Miller played through the torn labrum without complaint. They view that not as a red flag, but as proof of his toughness — the exact mentality they want in their locker room.
“We want dogs,” Moore said. “Christen Miller is a dog. Dogs play through pain. Dogs don’t make excuses.”
—
The Verdict: Genius or Gamble?
If the Saints are right — if Miller’s shoulder holds up and he plays 15-plus games per season — they just drafted a top-50 talent at No. 93 overall. A disruptive, violent, run-stuffing defensive tackle who makes everyone around him better. He becomes the heir to David Onyemata and the perfect complement to Bryan Bresee.
But if the Saints are wrong — if the shoulder fails again, if Miller needs a fourth surgery, if he becomes another name on the long list of Saints injury busts — this pick will haunt the franchise. It will be the moment fans point to as proof that Loomis never learned from his mistakes.
For now, New Orleans is divided. The optimists see a steal. The realists see a walking red flag.
One thing is certain: Every time Christen Miller makes a tackle this preseason, the entire city will hold its breath — waiting to see if that shoulder finally gives out.
The talent is real. The red flag is real. The fury is real.
Now, we wait to see which one wins.
—
